Best Black Hair Dye For Natural Hair

45 Products Considered
49 Hours of Research
4 Experts Interviewed
727 Reviews Analyzed

I’m sure you’ll agree with me when I say this:

Buying the best black hair dye for natural hair can be a challenge.

It can seem like there are hundreds or even thousands of beauty products to choose from but there’s nothing that fits your specific needs. Oh, we know that feeling.

Best Black Hair Dye For Natural Hair
Best Black Hair Dye For Natural Hair
L'Oreal Paris Superior Preference Glam Lights Highlights, GL70 Dark Blonde
  • Quick and easy blended highlights
  • Expert brush for perfect highlights in a stroke
  • Ultra-glamorous hair illumination

It sucks when you’ve got a budget to fit in and you want to find something that would be the best bang for the buck, but it’s impossible to narrow down the choices without spending hours (sometimes tens of hours) on research and reading the reviews on the best black hair dye.

We decided that it’s time for robots to do the hard work. Here’s how:

  1. With the help of Artificial Intelligence, we analyzed hundreds of thousands (no kidding) of reviews from verified owners on Amazon and reputable expert sources like Consumer Reports, The Wirecutter, PCmag, and many others.
  2. Every product got its own rating in each category (like “best something for natural hair”).
  3. We compiled lists of the best products in every category and created lists like the one you can see below
  4. We shared them with the public, so you guys could make informed decisions and save time.

For this article about the Best Black Hair Dye For Natural Hair we reviewed and evaluated more than 180+ black hair dyes. The AI (artificial) selected only those that received the top award. Only winners are listed below. You can see the highest overall rating of each item and a comprehensive breakdown of its characteristics.

Best Black Hair Dye For Natural Hair – Comparison Table

black hair dye Reviews and Buying Guide

With more choices than ever, it can be hard to find the black hair dye that’s right for you. And it can be frustrating to shop for the best black hair dye for natural hair, hoping to find the one that can help you. But don’t worry. With our tools and guides, we can help.

We provide consumers with the information they need to get the most out of their new purchases. We’ve discussed our favorite deals and services, and sorted out the strengths and weaknesses of each variation. We’ve even pinpointed what makes a good black hair dye, helping you identify and avoid the pitfalls of price gimmicks and overpriced beauty brands.

48 Reviews
  • Clarifies product build-up
  • Leaves hair shiny and manageable
  • Detoxes the scalp
1,384 Reviews
  • 25-count of soft, pre-moistened Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes to remove makeup and effectively cleanse skin in one easy step
  • Makeup remover towelettes work to dissolve all traces of dirt, oil and makeup on skin, for superior cleansing and makeup removing power at your fingertips
  • Remove 99.3% of all makeup—even stubborn waterproof mascara - with these eye makeup remover wipes which are specially formulated to be gentle on the eyes, so they're safe enough for contact lens wearers
  • Wipes are disposable and thoroughly cleanse skin without irritation and leave behind no heavy residue, so there's no need to rinse
  • Facial cleansing wipes feature an alcohol-free formula to cleanse while also being gentle on the face, and are ophthalmologist-, dermatologist-, and allergy-tested
1,310 Reviews
  • RADIANT HAIR COLOR WITH TRIPLE PROTECTION: No hair color cares more than Excellence Crème. With our triple protection system that seals, replenishes, and conditions, plus 100% gray coverage even on stubborn grays, it's called Excellence for a reason.
  • EXCELLENCE IN HAIR PROTECTION: Our weekly conditioning treatment with collagen helps protect hair until your next hair coloring, for long lasting radiance. For 100% gray coverage & gorgeous root-to-tip color, treat yourself to Excellence Creme hair color.
  • L'OREAL PERMANENT HAIR COLOR: L'Oreal Paris Hair Color comes in multiple formulations and styles to deliver long-lasting color, from fade-defying Superior Preference, to bold, stylish Feria, and gray-coverage from Excellence Crème.
  • LONG LASTING HAIR COLOR: Get beautiful color from root-to-tip with L'Oréal Paris hair color, permanent, semi-permanent, and root touch up kits. Cover gray hair, highlight, go bold with bright color, or even try an ombre hair color.
  • L'OREAL PARIS IS INCOMPARABLE: Tried at-home hair dyeing kits like Clairol Nice'N Easy, Schwarzkopf Keratin, Herbatint hair Color, Clairol Natural Instinct, Vidal Sassoon hair color, Naturtint hair color? We think you'll love L'Oreal Paris hair color.
348 Reviews
  • Pack of 3 Clairol Natural Instincts semi permanent hair color kits in Spiced Tea Light Auburn; Ammonia free hair dye with aloe & Color Treat Conditioner fades naturally without harsh root lines so your hair will be healthy & radiant from roots to tips
  • Natural Instincts hair color will infuse your hair with natural looking, radiant color that conditions; This semi permanent color fades naturally over 28 shampoos, so go for an easy brunette one month & a brilliant blond the next
  • Our Natural Instincts hair color lasts for 28 shampoos, fading naturally without harsh root lines to keep your hair looking radiant; Natural Instincts dye is semi permanent, so stay neutral with your natural hair color, or revel in revealing a new you
  • Our natural, radiant hair color in ammonia free shades with conditioner leaves your hair gorgeous from the roots to the tips; Reveal your hair's most brilliant shade with our multiple tones of hair dye colors in shades of black, brown, auburn, red & blond
  • All Natural Instincts hair coloring products for women & men are ammonia free, infused with antioxidants & conditioning aloe to give you long lasting, semi permanent & natural hair color using a treatment as nice and easy as a trip to your favorite salon
1,269 Reviews
  • Pack of 2 Clairol Nice 'n Easy Root Touch-Up Kits that matches shades of Dark Auburn/Medium Reddish Brown, including salon colors. The Precision Brush makes application easy & fast- conceal roots or gray hairs in minutes; coverage lasts up to 3 weeks.
  • It's only human to want perfect hair - you're one step closer with our permanent color that mixes in seamlessly no matter what leading shade you use. Touch up your roots & conceal gray in minutes with the included Precision Brush tool for easy application
  • The magic of Nice 'n Easy hair products is in helping you balance a desire for hair color that is perfect, easy & looks natural. Our products won't leave revealing or fake tones, just 100% gray coverage that leaves you looking naturally beautiful.
  • Nice 'n Easy carries superior hair color products from permanent hair color kits & tools, highlights and root touch ups that mix with colors applied by your salon colorist, gray hair concealer, to hair gloss to keep your hair looking natural & radiant.
  • Our Nice 'n Easy line of hair color products make superior, natural-looking color. Our hair coloring products provide beautifully color so natural looking even sunlight won't reveal your secret. Touch up your roots, try a new hair color, or add highlights.
  • Permanent color that blends seamlessly.
149 Reviews
  • GRAY COVERAGE HAIR COLOR WITH TRIPLE PROTECTION: No hair color cares more than Excellence Crème. With our triple protection system that seals, replenishes & conditions, plus 100% gray coverage even on stubborn grays, it's called Excellence for a reason.
  • EXCELLENCE IN HAIR PROTECTION: Our weekly conditioning treatment with collagen helps protect hair until your next hair coloring, for long lasting rich color. For 100% gray coverage and gorgeous root-to-tip color, treat yourself to Excellence hair color.
  • L'OREAL PERMANENT HAIR COLOR: L'Oreal Paris Hair Color comes in multiple formulations and styles to deliver long-lasting color, from fade-defying Superior Preference, to bold, stylish Feria, and gray-coverage from Excellence Crème.
  • LONG LASTING HAIR COLOR: Get beautiful color from L'Oréal Paris hair color; permanent, semi-permanent, temporary hair color, & root cover up. Cover gray hair, highlight, go bold with bright color, or even try an ombre hair color.
  • L'OREAL PARIS IS INCOMPARABLE: Tried at-home hair dyeing kits like Clairol Nice'N Easy, Schwarzkopf Keratin, Herbatint hair Color, Clairol Natural Instinct, Vidal Sassoon hair color, Naturtint hair color? We think you'll love L'Oreal Paris hair color.
20 Reviews
  • With liquid crystals. Brings out depth and richness in brunette hair.
479 Reviews
  • Permanent liquid hair color with Precision Applicator
  • Lasts up to 8 weeks
  • 100% gray coverage
  • Includes ColorSeal Conditioning Gloss to help seal in beautiful color and intense shine
2,059 Reviews
  • OIL POWERED PERMANENT HAIR DYE: Olia is an ammonia-free hair color kit for brilliant color and visibly healthier looking hair. Using an exclusive 60% oil blendwith natural flower oils, Olia has a unique no-drip cream formula.
  • AMMONIA-FREE HAIR COLOR: Olia transforms coloring your hair into a new sensorial experience. Because Olia hair dye is ammonia-free there is no harsh ammonia smell.
  • GARNIER HAIR COLOR: For hair-nourishing, easy-to-use permanent hair dye, temporary hair color, root touch up, or to enhance your natural hair color, turn to Garnier hair color.
  • OVER 100 YEARS OF PIONEERING IN HAIR CARE: Since 1904 Garnier has blended naturally inspired & derived ingredients into breakthrough formulas. Nourish your hair with hair color & care from Garnier.
  • GARNIER IS INCOMPARABLE: Tried at-home hair dyeing kits like Clairol Nice'N Easy, Schwarzkopf Keratin, Just for Men, Clairol Natural Instinct, Vidal Sassoon hair color, Naturtint hair color? We think you'll love Garnier hair color.
301 Reviews
  • Water- Proof Until You Shampoo it
  • Covers Grey Hair
  • Great for in between salon visits
  • Made in the USA
105 Reviews
  • Quick and easy blended highlights
  • Expert brush for perfect highlights in a stroke
  • Ultra-glamorous hair illumination
86 Reviews
  • Formulated without bleaching agents such as hydrogen peroxide and ammonia
  • Natural and gradual lightening of blond to light brown hair
  • Leaves hair soft, easy to detangle and full of radiance
32 Reviews
  • NO AMMONIA
  • NO PEROXIDE
  • NO ALCOHOL
  • EXTRA CONDITIONING SEMI PERMANENT HAIR COLOR
  • NO HEAT FORMULA

Price

If you buy a quality, top of the line black hair dye from a reliable brand and pay top dollar for it, you can be assured that it will perform to your liking.

Some price-conscious users seek out the cheapest products in the market to save money. These users want to make sure they get the best value at the lowest price without being scammed.

Other users simply want to get the best products and don’t care much about price.

We rated our top black hair dye list based on the quality first and only then price. So if you’re not sure whether you can afford an item, just click “Buy on Amazon” and check the price.

Last update on 2020-01-11 at 13:32 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.